Doppler changes in the main fetal brain arteries at different stages of haemodynamic adaptation in severe intrauterine growth restriction.
Aim and background of project
The objective is to evaluate changes in the temporal evolution and regional distribution of the arterial brain Doppler parameters in relation to different stages of hemodynamic adaptation in severe intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR).
IUGR associated with placental insufficiency and chronic hypoxia may complicate nearly 3-4% of all pregnancies. Up to 15% of all IUGR fetuses develop some degree of overt neurological damage, mainly expressed as hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, leukomalacia, and/or cerebral palsy. However, as more data becomes available, a wider spectrum of subtle brain developmental disturbances has been described, including neuromuscular disorders, learning disabilities and behavioural misconducts. The understanding of the adaptive processes occurring in the human fetal brain under growth restriction, and subsequently, the ability to predict neurological morbidity is still poor. In spite of the use of Doppler in the obstetrical management, the risk of suboptimal neurodevelopment in childhood in fetuses diagnosed with IUGR may occur in up to 50-60% of cases.
Growth restriction due to placental insufficiency is believed to be associated with chronic hypoxia, which in turn, triggers a blood flow centralisation process in order to maximise blood supply to key organs, such as the brain heart and adrenals. The temporal evolution of these changes during the process of fetal deterioration within the fetal brain, and the potential existence of regional variations has not been explored. In clinical practice, the centralisation process is identified by a reduction in the pulsatility index (PI) in the middle cerebral artery (MCA). It is unknown if these changes occur similarly in all cerebral arteries and their relationship to the fetal hemodynamic adaptation to severe growth restriction.
A regional hemodynamic redistribution could be one of the mechanisms to explain the existence of a regional hierarchy in brain deterioration, whereby certain areas are more susceptible to hypoxic damage. A few studies in IUGR fetuses have shown that different fetal brain arteries present a heterogeneous variation in the Doppler parameters in IUGR fetuses, thus supporting the concept that the human fetal brain might experience hemodynamic internal variations during hypoxic IUGR. However, the influence of the stage of fetal deterioration in these regional variations has not yet been studied. We aimed at evaluating the temporal sequence in the arterial brain blood flow Doppler parameters at different stages of fetal hemodynamic deterioration, and the potential differences in blood supply to different brain territories in fetuses affected with severe IUGR.
Method
Thirty six (36) singleton fetuses with severe IUGR, defined as: gestational age (GA) at diagnosis B32 weeks, estimated fetal growth <P10 and abnormal umbilical artery pulsatility index (UA-PI >2 SD) were studied longitudinally at intervals between 1 to 4 days until delivery. Median maternal age at the time of diagnosis was 31 years (range 22 - 39 years) and median gestational age at enrolment 26 weeks+2days (range, 25+2 – 32+0 weeks). All these fetuses underwent an evolution of hemodynamic changes that was classified in stages, as follows: stage 1 (n=36), umbilical artery pulsatility index (UA-PI) >2 SD or umbilical artery absent end diastolic flow (UA-AEDF), and middle cerebral artery PI (MCA-PI) mean ± 2SD; stage 2 (n=34), UA-PI >2 SD or UA-AEDF, and MCA-PI <2SD; stage 3 (n=30), reverse end diastolic UA blood flow and MCA-PI <2SD with present ductus venosus (DV) atrial flow; and stage 4 (n=12), reverse or absent atrial flow in the DV. All cases entered the study at hemodynamic stage 1 and only the first examination at each stage was recorded for the study. The reasons to indicate delivery were variable at different gestational ages: (1) before 28 weeks, absent or reversed atrial flow in the DV, (2) between 28 and 32 weeks, reversed end diastolic flow in the umbilical artery or persistently abnormal fetal heart rate traces and/or altered biophysical profile, (3) after 32 weeks, persistently abnormal middle cerebral artery PI(<2SD). Thus, a variable number of fetuses were delivered at each stage of hemodynamic deterioration. In addition, 36 normally grown fetuses at gestational age (median) 29+2 weeks’ GA (range, 28+1 - 32+0) were evaluated as controls. None of the cases or control fetuses had chromosomal or structural abnormalities. The project was approved by the institutional ethics committee and informed written consent was obtained in all cases.
Ultrasound and Doppler examinations were done with a Siemens/Antares US equipment with a 6-2 MHz curved linear array. All Doppler examinations were performed in absence of fetal corporal and respiratory movements and with the mother in voluntary suspended respiration. For the Doppler measurements, the angle of insonation was maintained below 30 degrees and corrected manually when necessary. Directional colour Doppler was used to clearly locate the different vessels and a minimum of 5 consecutive good quality waveforms measured. The mechanical and thermal indices were kept below 1. The mean examination time was 8 minutes (range 3-15 min).
Pulsed Doppler examination of the UA-PI was performed in a free loop of the umbilical cord, and in the DV in a transverse, or alternatively sagittal view of the fetal abdomen at its emergence from the portal vein. The fetal brain arterial circulation was studied in the following arteries: MCA; in a transverse view of the fetal head at the level of the sphenoid bone immediately after its origin from the circle of Willis; anterior cerebral (ACA) and pericallosal (PER) arteries, both located in a transverse plane with a frontal projection of the fetal head, where PER is located cranial to the ACA, and both vessels showed opposite colour Doppler pattern. In this projection the insonation angle was 0º. PCA was studied in a transverse plane with a posterior projection and a clear view of the cerebellum. PI and timeaveraged maximum velocity (TAMV) were recorded in all arteries. TAMV was analysed because it represents the movement of the blood cells travelling in the centre of the vessel during the complete cardiac cycle, and therefore, can be an indirect parameter of the blood volume.
Special attention was taken to avoid unnecessary pressure in the fetal head as the blood flow velocities could be greatly affected. All Doppler studies were performed by two operators (HFD and EHA).
The results of the MCA, DV and UA Doppler examination were available to the clinicians, but not the remaining measurements. The decision to deliver the fetus was taken at the discretion of managing physicians on the basis of current clinical protocols, as defined above.
Data were stored in databases and analysed with the SPSS 12.0 Statistical Package. Comparisons between IUGR and normal fetuses were tested with the Wilcoxon Mann- Whitney test. Differences within the IUGR hypoxic stages were estimated with the Kruscal-Wallis test and if present, confirmed with Wilcoxon Mann-Whitney test.
Results
The survival rate in the IUGR group was 86% (31/36), there were 2 fetal and 3 neonatal deaths. The two stillbirths showed reversed atrial flow in the ductus venosus before 28 weeks, and despite detailed counselling, the parents decided not to deliver the fetus. Clinical characteristics of both study groups at birth are summarised in Table 1.
Table 1: Clinical characteristics in the study groups.
| |
n=36 |
n=36 |
| Gestational age at delivery (weeks+days) |
29 + 3 |
39 + 5 |
| Median, range |
(26 + 1- 33 + 6) |
(36 + 5 – 41 + 3) |
| Birthweight (g) |
985 |
3217 |
| Mean, range |
(680 – 1336) |
(2870 – 3850) |
| 1’ Apgar |
7 |
9 |
| Median, range |
(1 - 9) |
(7 – 10) |
| 5’ Apgar |
9 |
10 |
| Median, range |
(4 – 10) |
(8 – 10) |
| Umbilical vein pH |
7.23 |
7.26 |
| Mean, range |
(7.12 – 7.34) |
(7.20 – 7.35) |
| Days in the NIUC |
36 |
- |
IUGR: intrauterine growth restriction, NIUC: neonatal intensive care unit
Doppler signals from all studied vessels were recorded in all cases. Table 2 shows the PI values in the 4 hemodynamic stages. Overall, IUGR fetuses showed a significant reduction in the PI values of all cerebral arteries as compared with controls. However, different patterns were observed in each vessel in relation to the hemodynamic adaptation. The anterior cerebral artery presented a steady decrease until stage 2, with no significant further changes. The middle cerebral and pericallosal arteries had minimal changes in stage 1, with a marked reduction in PI in stage 2 and a trend for increasing in stages 3 and 4. In contrast, the posterior cerebral artery showed a marked reduction in stage 1, which showed no significant variations in the remaining stages.
Table 2:
Pulsatility index (mean, SD) in the fetal brain arteries at different stages of the hemodynamic adaptation.
| |
|
Stage 1 |
Stage 2 |
Stage 3 |
Stage 4 |
| |
n = 36 |
n = 36 |
n = 34 |
n = 30 |
n = 12 |
| Anterior cerebral artery |
1.74 |
1.37* |
1.15* |
1.17* |
1.14* |
| |
(0.3) |
(0.3) |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
(0.3) |
| Middle cerebral artery |
2.01 |
1.75* |
1.32* |
1.56* |
1.65* |
| |
(0.3 |
(0.4) |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
| Posterior cerebral artery |
1.63 |
1.16* |
1.17* |
1.15* |
1.16* |
| |
(0.3) |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
(0.3) |
| Pericallosal artery |
1.54 |
1.48 |
1.12* |
1.38 |
1.48 |
| |
(0.2) |
(0.2) |
(0.3) |
(0.2) |
(0.3) |
IUGR, intrauterine growth restriction;
-
Stage 1 - Umbilical artery pulsatility index (UA-PI) mean >2 SD or absent UA end diastolic flow
-
Stage 2 - middle cerebral artery PI (MCA-PI) mean <2SD
-
Stage 3 - reverse UA end diastolic flow
-
Stage 4 - absent or reverse atrial flow in the ductus venosus. *: p<0.05 as compared with controls.
In general, TAMV values showed a mirror-like response with respect to PI values, with the exception of the posterior cerebral artery (Table 3). In stage 1, all vessels had small and non-significant differences with respect to controls. In stage 2, values increased significantly by 43 to 61% in the anterior, middle cerebral and pericallosal arteries, whereas the posterior cerebral artery experienced a modest (18%) non-significant increment. In stages 3 and 4, TAMV in the ACA and PER remained unchanged whereas in the MCA showed a trend to decrease.
Table 3: Time-averaged maximum velocity (mean, SD) in the fetal brain arteries at different stages of hemodynamic adaptation in IUGR fetuses.
| |
|
Stage 1 |
Stage 2 |
Stage 3 |
Stage 4 |
| |
n = 36 |
n = 36 |
n = 34 |
n = 30 |
n = 12 |
| Anterior cerebral artery |
13.8 |
15.2 |
21.5* |
22.3* |
21.8* |
| |
(4.0) |
(5.0) |
(5.0) |
(5.2) |
(5.1) |
| Middle cerebral artery |
18.3 |
20.8 |
26.2* |
25.2* |
25.1* |
| |
(4.3) |
(6.1) |
(4.7) |
(4.2) |
(6.0) |
| Posterior cerebral artery |
14.8 |
16.6 |
17.7 |
17.3 |
16.8 |
|
(6.0) |
(4.2) |
(3.7) |
(4.1) |
(4.7) |
| Pericallosal artery |
10.1 |
11.2 |
15.3* |
16.8* |
16.4* |
IUGR, intrauterine growth restriction;
-
Stage 1 - Umbilical artery pulsatility index (UA-PI) mean >2 SD or absent UA end diastolic flow
-
Stage 2 - middle cerebral artery PI (MCA-PI) <2SD
-
Stage 3 - reverse UA end diastolic flow
-
Stage 4 - absent or reverse atrial flow in the ductus venosus. *: p<0.05 as compared with controls.
Discussion
The results of this study showed different temporal changes in the fetal cerebral arteries in relation to the systemic hemodynamic changes occurring in severe IUGR. In terms of the PI, the ACA and the PCA seem to respond earlier, showing a significant reduction in stage I. In terms of velocity, TAMV showed a mirror-like behaviour with respect to pulsatility in the ACA, MCA and PER, suggesting that the reduction in the PI in these vessels was probably associated with increments in blood supply. However, this increase in TAMV was not observed in the PCA, in spite of a profound reduction in PI values. This may suggest the existence of redistribution processes whereby some brain territories might fail to increase blood supply as effectively as others.
There are few reports addressing the simultaneous investigation of the main fetal cerebral arteries. In normal pregnancies, Hata et al. reported a reduction in the resistance index of the ACA, MCA and PCA from 28 weeks onwards. In IUGR fetuses, van den Wijngaard et al. showed a constantly reduced PCA-PI value (mean <2SD) as compared with MCA-PI and ACAPI. Conversely, Noordam et al. found that MCA-PI was the artery with the most pronounced changes in IUGR fetuses and, recently Dubiel et al. in a group of high-risk pregnancies, described that ACA-PI showed the highest association with an adverse perinatal outcome. All these studies agree with the notion of a general reduction in the cerebral vascular resistance, but differ on which vessel is most affected. A poor case-specific definition of IUGR, lack of longitudinal evaluation, and differences in severity and gestational age at enrolment could explain the reported differences. Our findings are in line with those by Dubiel et al., who described the ACA as the artery showing the earliest changes in growth restriction. In addition, in this study we also found that the PCA also presented an earlier response. This observation is based on, despite in hemodynamic stage 1 all fetuses have a normal MCA-PI value, some of them already showed significantly reduced ACA-PI and PCA-PI values, as compared with controls.
Another observation in this study was that from stage 2 onwards, PI values failed to decrease. It is possible that the fetal brain reaches the maximal vascular vasodilation response already by stage 2, as defined in this study. In the presence of more severe hemodynamic changes (reverse umbilical end diastolic flow and absent or reverse atrial flow in the ductus venosus) PI values from the MCA and PER arteries even tended to increase. This finding was previously reported by Konje et al. who described an increment in MCA-PI, or reversal adaptation, in severely affected IUGR fetuses. They also described a reduction in the MCA volume blood flow prior to the increment in the MCA-PI. The opposite pattern observed between MCATAMV and MCA-PI at hemodynamic stages 3 and 4 are in accordance with this observation. Furthermore, we observed a similar behaviour in the pericallosal artery.
This study presents several limitations. The evaluated parameters are only indirect estimates of true blood perfusion. As illustrated in this study, changes in pulsatility may not necessarily imply true changes in the organ blood perfusion. Although also an indirect estimate, the second parameter used in this study, TAMV, may provide more relevant information on blood supply. Another potential limitation is that the evaluated arteries provide blood supply to ill-defined anatomic areas with a marked component of vascular shunting, and therefore, the data should not be used to infer which territories are specifically involved in the observed changes. The use of recently described techniques to evaluate tissue perfusion might allow researchers to explore in detail the potential changes in specific regions. Such studies are now underway. Finally, our definition of the progression of fetal hemodynamic adaptation was based on experimental and clinical reports where a continuous insult, probably hypoxia, produces an increment of the peripheral tissue resistance, followed by a sequence of fetal cardiovascular protective mechanisms. While we cannot exclude some degree of overlapping between the clinical cases, we believe that the classification used identified fetuses at different stages of hemodynamic adaptation.
To our knowledge, this is the first longitudinal and simultaneous study of the three major fetal brain arteries, and the first addressing the pericallosal artery in the hypoxic fetus. Analysis of these vessels contributes to important information on the adaptive hemodynamic brain changes, and the progression of fetal deterioration occurring in presence of chronic fetal hypoxia. The data supports the notion that hemodynamic brain changes could be used to understand the sequence of processes leading to irreversible neurological damage.
This information is not meant to replace the advice of any physician or qualified health professional. The information provided by Cerebra is for information purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical condition. You should promptly seek professional medical assistance if you have concerns regarding any health issue.